Whether you’re looking for a classic ice cream experience or a quick treat on the go, Henry County has several establishments for everyone. With a variety of ice cream shops to choose from, you’re sure to find the perfect spot to cool down on a hot summer day.
From hand-dipped ice cream and milkshakes to specialty floats and sundaes, these ice cream shops will satisfy your cravings and create lasting memories. So, embrace the sweet side of life and embark on a delightful ice cream adventure in Henry County, Indiana!
At the Whitetail Sweet Shop, you can choose from an array of hand-dipped and soft-serve ice cream, milkshakes, malts, and specialty drinks. Try an Ice Cream Flight featuring four small scoops of your favorite flavors for a special treat. This allows you to enjoy several of Sundaes Homemade Ice Cream’s hand-dipped ice cream flavors. If you’re looking for a wider selection, their menu includes energy drinks, specialty sodas, smoothies, slushies, hot dogs, nachos, and pretzel sticks.
Just beyond Summit Lake State Park, The Summit Lake Market is both a Christian camp store and a charming ice cream shop. It boasts an extensive menu featuring hand-scooped ice cream from the delicious Sundaes Homemade Ice Cream brand, dairy-free sherbet, and aromatic coffee from Greenfield Coffee Co. (try a coffee float!), making it a popular destination for locals and visitors.
Weenee World offers drive-thru and walk-up options in New Castle, serving ice cream and treats for decades. Their carnival-themed menu offers a wide range of hand-dipped and soft-serve ice cream, sundaes, flurries, sno balls, slushies, strawberry shortcakes, funnel fries, cotton candy, caramel corn, and more. You’ll choose from an extensive selection of flavors and toppings, and they also cater to special dietary needs with sugar-free, gluten-free, and dairy-free options. Beyond desserts, Weenee World offers burgers, tenderloins, sandwiches, coney dogs, and an array of small bites.
Dairy King
Dairy King, a locally owned establishment, provides an assortment of ice cream delights, including sundaes, shakes, Twisters, and malts. For those craving something more, they serve a smash burger, barbeque sandwiches, hot dogs, and fries. Dairy King’s walk-up window is open seven days a week, welcoming guests from 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to experience their delightful offerings!
In New Castle, Culver’s, a well-known chain restaurant, has rapidly gained popularity for its frozen custard, cold treats, and food options. Locals frequently congregate here for lunch or dinner, anticipating the daily frozen custard flavor and an assortment of concrete mixers, malts, shakes, sundaes, and root beer floats crafted using Culver’s root beer.
In Knightstown, step inside Delish and enjoy a menu featuring hand-dipped ice cream in various flavors, milkshakes, classic banana splits, and refreshing frappes. Delish doesn’t stop at frozen desserts; its menu also boasts an array of savory options, including authentic Mexican dishes, burgers, and hot dogs. You can dine in or take your order to go.
Lewisville General Store
In Lewisville stands the historic Lewisville General Store—a nostalgic soda fountain that serves milkshakes and ice cream sodas, perfect for washing down the renowned Harrold’s burgers and tenderloins. Each sip and bite promises a delightful journey into the past, making the Lewisville General Store a fun stop for anyone seeking an old-fashioned treat.
Frosty Boy K
The beloved family-run establishment Frosty Boy K has recently reopened its doors. It offers a wide range of sweet delights, including classic ice cream treats like shakes, floats, sundaes, and flurries. For those wanting food, Pizza King pizzas and subs are available. With the convenience of a drive-thru, walk-up window, and indoor seating, Frosty Boy K has dining options for everyone. Please note that they only accept cash or local checks as payment.
– Article by Jamie Ward, Travel Writer, Cornfields & High Heels
